Every single PS2 HD I've used has died on me. The first one died after I took it out of the adapter. It started clicking. The second one, same thing. And the third one, also the same thing. But for the third one, Windows knows its there, but its not being recognized by WinHIIP or Disk Manager.
I'm going to stop trying my luck with them (Thank god I got all of them for free).
But if a PS2 HD Guru can help me save the third drive, because its recognized a nd not clicking, it will be greatly appretiated.