The conductive plastic mat that connects the buttons has one of it's conductive ink traces broken. Unfortunately the only real repair is replacing the plastic mat or repainting the broken trace with conductive ink.
Honestly it's cheaper for you find another controller(s).
SCPH-10000_GH-001 SCPH-15000_GH-003 SCPH-18000_GH-008 SCPH-30001_GH-005 SCPH-30000_GH-016(V4) SCPH-30001_GH-010(V4)
2xSCPH-10190, 2xSCPH-10350, 2xSCPH-10280
"**** j0 hackers!"
-Sjeep (As seen on TOXIC OS ELF...)