PSX-SCENE Forum Discussion for Sony PlayStation/PsOne/PS2/PS3/PSP/PS VITA
  • Sony Sued in Patent Infringement Oven PSN!

    Looks like Sony has crossed the line again, and apparently this time Apple, too. You see, both companies are being sued over patent infringement. Apparently somone pateneted the idea of vending digital media to multiple devices. That could be why we are only seeing these companys being hit with the lawsuit, because iTunes covers the iPad, iPod, iPhone, AppleTV even; and Sony's PSN covers PSP, PS Vita, and PS3.


    Don't take my word for it, read below a quote from the source.

    Apple, Sony Sued in California Patent Infringement Claim Over iTunes, Playstation Network Systems

    PALO ALTO, Calif. – The inventor of technology used in data vending systems such as the iTunes and Playstation Network systems has sued Cupertino, Calif.-based Apple Inc. (NYSE: APPL) and Foster City, Calif.-based Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC (NYSE: SNE) for patent infringement.

    Inventor Benjamin Grobler is represented by intellectual property attorneys Christopher Banys and Richard C. Lin from the Palo Alto, Calif., office of The Lanier Law Firm. The lawsuits filed March on 27, 2012, allege that Apple and Sony are infringing U.S. Patent No. 6,799,084.

    The United States Patent and Trademark Office issued the ‘084 patent to Mr. Grobler in 2004. The patent covers data vending systems that allow users to store and manage digital music, video, software and other items on a variety of electronic devices.

    According to the lawsuit, Apple and Sony have infringed the patent by making and offering infringing data vending systems such as iTunes and the Playstation Network, and that the companies are inducing their customers’ infringement by using these systems.

    “You would be hard pressed to find someone who hasn’t listened to music or watched a video through iTunes or the Playstation Network,” says Mr. Banys, head of the nationwide intellectual property practice at The Lanier Law Firm. “Tech giants can’t just take an inventor’s work and use it as their own. This lawsuit represents our client’s effort to bring some accountability to the system.”

    The cases are Benjamin Grobler v. Apple Inc., No. CV-12-1534, and Benjamin Grobler v. Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, No. CV-12-1526. Both are pending in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.
    These guys say they are out for justice, but we might end up just seeing a setlement and nothing changed.

    Sources:
    Comments 11 Comments
    1. Yden's Avatar
      Yden -
      Is this real or an April Fools joke?
    1. tthousand's Avatar
      tthousand -
      We don't do those!
    1. One2thr456svn's Avatar
      One2thr456svn -
      Ok he is going after both Apple and $ony.....As much as I would like to see something change, it is not likely.
    1. tthousand's Avatar
      tthousand -
      No, it is more likely they get some cash, and the law turns their check. That's politics for you.
    1. Zangetsu21's Avatar
      Zangetsu21 -
      Give it a week or two, this guy is gonna walk away with 2 HUGE "settlements" *cough* bribes *cough* and both Sony and Apple will walk free. This my friends is "justice" in our world. Only those with tons of money get away with everything.
    1. tthousand's Avatar
      tthousand -
      It will be interesting to watch, and get a good look a "justice". Not nice, interesting though. Damn...
    1. yes159's Avatar
      yes159 -
      It is cases like this that shows how crazy the US Patent Office can be. Seriously, having patent on just the idea of offering/managing video and music etc. on multiply devices from one service? What is the next thing, that someone has patent on cloud storage?

      I could understand if it this Grobler guy had invented a brand new protocol for these things and other companies used this protocol without permission, but this sounds like he have patent on the idea alone, which is pretty crazy when we are talking about something this broad.
    1. itzViolence's Avatar
      itzViolence -
      I love to hear apple is getting sued again, god I hate this company so much
    1. Nogitsune's Avatar
      Nogitsune -
      you've gotta be kidding me.. its been years since psn is up and this guy just remembered he invented something?
      its too fishy
    1. xboxmods2977's Avatar
      xboxmods2977 -
      Quote Originally Posted by Nogitsune View Post
      you've gotta be kidding me.. its been years since psn is up and this guy just remembered he invented something?
      its too fishy
      Sounds like he is a patent troll.

      Patent Troll - A person who purchases a patent, often from a bankrupt firm, and then sues another company by claiming that one of its products infringes on the purchased patent
    1. tthousand's Avatar
      tthousand -
      Or... the law firm could be the ones who seeked him out. Apparently, these guys are known for these kind of hit and runs, often ending in settlements.
  • Daily Digest


    Want to receive the latest PSX info in your email?

    Sign up for our Daily Digest!



    Want to learn more about the team keeping you up to date with the latest scene news?

    Read about them now!

    Check out our Developer bios, too!

  • Recent Threads

    rvuy9645

    Looking for: PS2 network adapter [EUR]

    Thread Starter: rvuy9645

    Hello,

    Looking for a network adaptor in Europe.
    I'm living in Belgium.
    Want to upgrade my fat PS2 with a HDD.
    Anybody

    Last Post By: rvuy9645 Today, 06:18 PM Go to last post
    SonyUSA

    iPod Touch 5th Gen Digitizer Replacement Guide !

    Thread Starter: SonyUSA

    Welcome to SonyUSA's Totally Amazing Digitizer Only iPod Touch 5th Generation Replacement Guide! V. 1.0!
    *trumpets!*

    Guide made for

    Last Post By: SonyUSA Today, 04:54 PM Go to last post
    PS456

    Weird Fragmentation problem

    Thread Starter: PS456

    Okay, a couple months ago i used Opl for my backups constantly. Eventually i grew bored, and got rid of all the backups and formatted my usb. Now i tried

    Last Post By: PS456 Today, 04:34 PM Go to last post
    ANTZ7

    About fight night champion

    Thread Starter: ANTZ7

    Has anybody managed to successfully resisgn
    Fight night champ I can't resign the save file to another user name I done a few games but just can

    Last Post By: worrorfight Today, 05:50 PM Go to last post
    jknee00

    ps2 SCPH 90001 DATE CODE 2B

    Thread Starter: jknee00

    i just wandering if this model can be exploited

    Last Post By: tommyv Today, 05:51 PM Go to last post
    barelynotlegal

    help with resigning saves to new profile(and a few others Q's)

    Thread Starter: barelynotlegal

    first off all i would like to say thanX to stoker, for his psid patch, i now have my banned console spoofed to a legitamate console id. i have made a

    Last Post By: ANTZ7 Today, 07:41 PM Go to last post
  • Recent Comments

    FrogDR

    3K3Y -- PS3 Blu Ray ODD Emulator

    could you show a links to the info with M$ and way to detect x360key users ? Go to last post

    FrogDR Today 07:40 PM
    diegsmoran

    PS2 Controller Remapper v1.00 - by pelvicthrustman

    Wow, this is way cool. Definatly useful for JP games using the X button to select! or changing some... Go to last post

    diegsmoran Today 05:21 PM
    elmaki

    [GTA IV] Major Distribution Mod Loader by ICECOLDKILLAH

    good gooodddd Go to last post

    elmaki Today 04:34 PM
    elmaki

    [GTA IV] Major Distribution Mod Loader by ICECOLDKILLAH

    que makinaaaaaaaaa Go to last post

    elmaki Today 04:34 PM
    pelvicthrustman

    PS2 Controller Remapper v1.00 - by pelvicthrustman

    PS2Classic should work as well but the code would have to be made into an ELF hack, as described in... Go to last post

    pelvicthrustman Today 03:46 PM
    b0redkid

    {Guide} How to make themes for multiMAN

    great! I will dabble in the arts after the holiday weekend, cheers! Go to last post

    b0redkid Today 02:53 PM
    MateoGodlike

    Bite v1.5 Released - PSP-PS3 Conversions- PSP Mini/Remaster/Homebrew Support

    Ill check and make sure. I'm pretty sure some of them might work. Go to last post

    MateoGodlike Today 02:32 PM
    bitsbubba

    {Guide} Install multiMAN Themes via a PKG File

    I think installing a theme from inside multiMAN is a better choice than from XMB that way you can... Go to last post

    bitsbubba Today 01:40 PM
    LKJHGFDSA

    Comedy on Demand: Laugh Factory on PS3 Updated

    $3 per month?
    Is there any free content or trial available? Go to last post

    LKJHGFDSA Today 11:48 AM
    brunolee

    {Guide} Install multiMAN Themes via a PKG File

    On PS3 THMs is a package for multiMAN themes, PKGs is a instalation package, put THMs in pkg only... Go to last post

    brunolee Today 11:02 AM